English @ YWPS
  • Home
  • News
  • Awards
    • Yearly Highlights
    • Speech Festival
    • Hong Kong Budding Poets Award
    • Hong Kong Young Writers Awards
    • Drama Festival
    • Debating Contests
  • Publications
    • FLAME Magazine
    • Anthologies
    • ACE Journal
    • Articles / Reports
  • English Language Curriculum
    • Language Arts >
      • Speech Gala
      • Drama in English
      • Creative Writing Competition >
        • 2021-2022 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2020-2021 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2019-2020 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2018-2019 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2017-2018 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2016-2017 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2015-2016 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2014-2015 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
    • Reading Programmes >
      • Children's Literature
      • RSTS
      • Reading Log
      • Reading Championship
  • English Room
    • Book Recommendations
  • Videos
    • Videos 2022-2023
    • Videos 2021-2022
    • Videos 2020-2021
    • Videos 2019-2020
    • Videos 2018-2019
    • Videos 2017-2018
    • Videos 2016-2017
    • Videos 2015-2016
    • Videos 2014-2015
    • Videos 2013-2014
    • Videos 2012-2013
  • Gallery
    • Snapshots 2021-2022
    • Snapshots 2020-2021
    • Snapshots 2019-2020
    • Snapshots 2018-2019
    • Snapshots 2017-2018
    • Snapshots 2016-2017
    • Snapshots 2015-2016
    • Snapshots 2014-2015
  • Contact

"To Be Continued..." Chapter 7 Launched!

6/2/2022

204 Comments

 
[2 Jun] "To Be Continued..." has come to its 7th chapter! More unbelievable things happens after Chi-yin recovers from his disability...Bong's identity is in question, Na Na reveals the secrets of the Old Wise Man, and our heroes have little idea what is waiting for them next! The story is reaching its climax soon! Watch the chapter again here for all clues and mysteries!
Picture
Intriguingly, in this chapter, the boys didn't throw their dice and thus no obvious hints are given. But does it mean there won't be any clues you can find in school? This puzzle is certainly "to be continued..."

​Now boys, question time. Here are two thoughtful questions for you. Feel free to answer one or both of them:

​
1. Na Na talks a lot about the secrets she knows. Do you think she has told the truth? What makes you believe or not believe her?
2. The Old Wise Man seems to be "inviting" the heroes to attend his "concert". What do you think he intends to do and why?
204 Comments
6E 21 Henry Tong
6/2/2022 06:39:54 pm

Q.1 I think she is telling the truth, because Bong is the person who saved her from the soilders and she doesn't look like that she is a betrayer

Reply
5E 25 Anson Tam
6/6/2022 09:45:24 pm

I think Na Na has told the truth because Bong have saved her life and she really always say Mind The Wise to the three heroes so I think she has told the truth

Reply
6B13 Max Sze
6/2/2022 06:40:56 pm

2. I think the Old Wise Man intends to trap the three heroes. It is because the video said that the seven sacred items that the heroes got were to feed Gauwa, so I think the Old Wise Man will trap them for his master evil plan.

Reply
Caleb Leung
7/21/2022 09:17:40 am

We know Guawa didn't insist.

Reply
6A 07 Adran Chan
6/2/2022 07:03:37 pm

1.In my opinion, I think Nana was just making up the "secrets", she was helping the old wise man to find out how much did they turst the old wise man.

Reply
Anson Tam
6/6/2022 09:48:17 pm

I think he wants to kill the heroes because he knows they knew about his secret and they will talk to everyone in forgettenland

Reply
6D23 Ambrose Wong
6/2/2022 07:08:59 pm

2. I think that the Old Wise Man wants to have Guawa reach his (its) final form, and he will use the seven sacred items (the robot was controlled by the old wise man, and it will help the Old Wise Man to succeed in the journey to conquer the world, or whatever he plans) to feed Guawa. I think that the seven ‘sacred’ items are the negative items which Na Na was talking about. Like the broken key and the C-shaped handle, they are broken, causing negative emotions coming from their inventors or founders. Those items might be the last ‘negative items’ to fully enhance Guawa to its final form, and Guawa’s force may be unstoppable. Lastly, The Old Wise Man might use the Pipa to reinforce Guawa even more, and he may succeed in whatever his plan may be.

Reply
6B10
6/2/2022 07:42:12 pm

Q2. I think the old wise man is lying about the concert. Maybe he is luring them into a trap, secretly feeding not only the sacred items to Gauwa, but the heroes themselves. That’s why all of the heroes before Bong and the others failed.

Reply
6E 17 Mike Lee
6/2/2022 07:46:31 pm

1. I think Nana told the truth because she looks kind and won't lie. I think she needs the final truth too.

Reply
Ethan Cheng
6/2/2022 07:54:08 pm

Q1. I think Na Na is telling the truth and here’s why: firstly, if she is telling lies, then why did the old wise man wanted to capture her, secondly, because she also have the dices which are used in the hula hoop.
Q2. I think it is a trap, because I think the old wise man already knows that Na Na told them the truth, so the old wise man wants to prevent the heros from spoiling the truth to more people so that the old wise man wanted to capture them.

Reply
James So 6A24
6/2/2022 08:08:31 pm

1. I think that Nana is not telling the truth.

A few evidence:
Why she knows about the old wise man?
Why she went with the robot in the smoke?

We can know that Nana isn't that simple and innocent

Reply
6D22 Constantine Wong
6/2/2022 09:20:43 pm

1. I don’t think Nana is telling the truth. I think she said that she was once the old wise man’s workers is to test if Bong is really loyal to the old wise man.
2. I think is it a trap. I think the old wise man will just capture them and use Guawa to kill them.

Reply
6D19 poon
6/2/2022 09:48:24 pm

q2: i think he will kill the 3 people to pretend that they are defeated by gauwa and use the items to feed it.

Reply
Anthony Pan 6D18
6/2/2022 09:59:06 pm

1. I think that Nana is telling the truth because she was hunted by the old wise man as the old wise man is terrified that she would expose his evil plans.
2. I think that the old wise man is trying to trick Bong, Chi-yin and Hinson to go to the concert, but in reality the old wise man would feed the three boys to Gauwa so that it can reach its most powerful form.

Reply
Daniel Yu
6/2/2022 10:10:57 pm

Q2 I think he will kill or attack them when they are in the “concert”. I think this was what The Old Wise Man wanted to do from the beginning.

Reply
Vincent Ng 6C 16
6/2/2022 10:30:20 pm

Q2 I think the old wise man wanted to hypnotise the heros with music and make them his minions because the old wise man knew that the heros knew too much about his secret plans/ so he'll make them his minions so while he can get rid of his enemies, he can also make his army grow.

Reply
6C10 Marco Leung
6/2/2022 10:54:44 pm

I think Nana is telling the truth because saved her from the soldiers, and I think she is finding the truth too.

Reply
Justin Yan
6/2/2022 11:01:29 pm

Q1.I think Nana is telling the truth because she was being chased by the warriors and the old wise man really looked furious when Nana escapes once again.Also Nana helps Bong to fight the 'Robot'Bong.
Q2.I think the old wise man intends to told the truth to the three boys at the 'concert' and feed Guawa by the seven 'negative' items and kill them after the old wise man finishes feeding Guawa.

Reply
6C 12 Gaspard Leung
6/2/2022 11:45:06 pm

2. I think the old wise man is going to feed the seven sacred items to Gauwa, making him reach his final form, then he will lock the three boys up in a cage and let them watch as he destroys and conquers the world with his creation Gauwa.

Reply
5E 06 Timothy Fung
6/3/2022 07:35:51 am

1.I think Na Na is telling the truth because when the 'robot ' Bong was coming towards the real Bong and Na Na,Na Na pushed the 'robot' Bong into the dark mist at once.Maybe the robot was made by the Wise Man.If Na Na wasn't telling the truth,then she just needed to help the robot.
2.I think the 'concert ' was actually a concert.But the people in there were Gauwa,a lot of.The Old Wise Man told the first Gauwa to come back from the Dark Mountain and copied many Gauwa.

Reply
Aydan Lee李朗銳5A 15
6/3/2022 07:46:55 am

Q.1 I think Na Na is telling the truth, because she 1) Gave Bong a 'sacred' item and 2) Got kidnapped by the Old Wise Man.

Q.2 I think the 'concert' was a concert, but he wants to take their 'sacred' items and hyptonize them too.

Reply
6C20 Brody Tong
6/3/2022 08:22:03 am

1. I think Nana has not told the truth. I think the old wise man wants to use Nana to trick the heros. Nana is told to tell some of the truth to earn trust from the heros.

2. I think the old wise man intends to capture the heros. When the heros come to the party, the old wise man will summon people to capture them. It is because the old wise man wants to force the heros to work for him.

Reply
Jovan Lau
6/3/2022 08:31:42 am

2.I think the old wise man is going to feed the seven sacred items to Gauwa, making him reach his final form, then he will lock the three boys up in a cage and let them watch as he destroys and conquers the world with his creation Gauwa

Reply
Jovan Lau
6/3/2022 08:34:06 am

1.I think nana is telling the truth because she is also a victim of the old wise man and also she kept warning people"Mind The Wise"

Reply
Tsui Chin Ho Jayden
6/3/2022 08:35:22 am

Q1. I think that NaNa said the truth. It was because Bong had helped him .

Reply
5B05 Keith Cheung
6/3/2022 09:30:21 am

Q1.Yes, I think Na Na is telling the truth because she treats Bong as a good friend, maybe Na Na has some special relationship with the old wise man, that's why she know so much about him.

Q2.I think he wants to kill the three heroes, at the time before Bong, Chi-yin and Hinson, many heroes died trying to defeat Gauwa but they all failed. This is probably the act of the old wise man

Reply
6B03MarcoCheung
6/3/2022 09:31:43 am

1. I think that NaNa tells the tells the truth, because she is kidnapped by the old wise man.

Reply
5C29 Ethan Wu
6/3/2022 09:42:42 am

I think Nana is not telling the truth, because the dice showed that there was a betrayer, so she will probably help the old wise man to kill the three boys.

Reply
5E20 Kingston Lo King Hang
6/3/2022 10:04:50 am

Q1)No, I think Na Na is not telling the truth, it is because I think she might be helping the Old Wise Man or else the Old Wise Man won't tell her the top secrets.
Q2)I think it is because the Old Wise Man want to let the 3 boys watch the Gauwa be much powerful hopelessly(So cruel!!!)

Reply
5D 07 TaydenFung
6/3/2022 10:05:41 am

1. I think Nana is telling the truth, because Bong is the one who saved her. And she wanted to repay him.

Reply
Travis Ho 5D08
6/3/2022 10:12:07 am

1. I think NaNa was a spy from the Old Wise Man so that he could learn more about the three boys and to think of a trap to trap them.

Reply
5A 25
6/3/2022 10:13:38 am

I think the old wise man will use the 7 sacred items to feed Gawa and kill Chi-Yin ,Hinson and Bong🍴

Reply
5D19 Li Wan Lam
6/3/2022 10:18:06 am

Q1.I think Na Na is telling the truth.It is because Bong helped Na Na before so she should help him back.

Reply
Ethan Leung 5A 16
6/3/2022 10:29:02 am

Q1 I think that Nana is telling the truth because the Old Wose Man wanted to kidnap her.
Q2 I think he wanted to kidnap the heroes.

Reply
6D 17
6/3/2022 10:32:03 am

1. I think Nana didn't tell the whole thing's truth but some of them, but it's confusing why she fought with the robot Bong who was sent by the Old Wise Man(maybe) if she worked for him years ago?

Reply
5D29
6/3/2022 10:32:34 am

1. I think Nana is telling the truth, because if she is not, the Old Wise Man would capture her.

Reply
5C 14 Jaden
6/3/2022 10:34:26 am

1. I think Na Na isn't telling the truth about her knowledge of the old wise man. First of all, I still think the old wise man is evil but instead of Na Na escaping from him, she actually works for him. I also don't believe her because when she first met Bong why didn't she tell him immediately about the old wise man, maybe because she wanted to use Bong to get the other items. Except for that, how would she know that 1. the old wise man created Guawa and 2. how would she know what Guawa eats. Maybe she is the person who feeds him.
2. I think he intends to use the and lead them towards Guawa and then he would tell them to give Guawa the "sacred items" and the Guawa would help the old wise man end the three heroes.

Reply
5C24 Samuel Tsang
6/3/2022 10:38:28 am

1. I think Nana is telling the truth, because Bong has help her once, and she warned people to "Mind the wise", so I think she wasn't the same team with the Old Wise Man.

Reply
5E8 Eric Lai
6/3/2022 10:43:44 am

Interesting question...
I personally have no idea,and have weak evidence,so instead of my personal view,I will talk about chances.
There are many possibilities,and Na Na can both be telling the truth or lies with different hidden meanings.
If she is telling a lie for good means,she might just be making up stories to test the loyalty of the three heroes,which there are no evidence supporting this.
If she is telling a lie for bad means,she will lie to confuse the three heroes,and make a bad imprint of the Old Wise Man,and maybe she is working not for the Old Wise Man,but Gauwa,which again have no evidence supporting this.
On the other hand,she might be telling the truth,but only to scare the three heroes,which is just an completely unrealistic idea,cause why will she be thinking that?
The most evidential thought is she is telling the truth by good means,because we,from the things the Old Wise Man did,the robot,the guards,etc.

Reply
Desmond Au 5A 01
6/3/2022 11:01:20 am

I think Na Na is telling the truth, because Bong is her friend who have saved her before, as a repay, Na Na told Bong the screct about The Old Wise Man.

Reply
5D01 Herman Au link
6/3/2022 11:11:59 am

1. I think Nana is telling the truth because she looked very innocent
2. I think the "concert" is a trap to kill the "heroes". yeah sus

Reply
Andrew Huang 5A08
6/3/2022 11:20:38 am

I don’t think Nana is telling the truth, because she shouldn’t know the secret of the old wise man.

Reply
6D24 Yau Cheuk Lok
6/3/2022 11:33:58 am

I believe Nana is suspicious because the fake Bong robot appeared out of nowhere. The robot was clearly malfunctioning but Nana did not seem surprised to know something was pretending to be Bong. Instead she knocked the robot away like the robot was giving away the plan that she and the old wise man had made up. The old wise man was obviously a fake because Bong was nearly captured by him. In conclusion, Nana is sus.

Reply
Samuel Leung 6C 11
6/3/2022 11:34:03 am

1. I think Nana is telling the truth, since she seems innocent and was willing to help Bong chase away the Robot Bong which I think is made by the Old Wise Man.
2. I think the "concert" is a trap to capture the heroes, petrify them into terracotta warriors and take the so called "sacred items" which are just random scraps to feed Gauwa.

Reply
Thomas Suen5A21
6/3/2022 11:36:53 am

Q1:I personally think the old wise man was actually not the people of the forgotten land, and was from the future. He probably was travelling by time so that every forgotten land people didn't know a lot about him. Hence NaNa was telling Bong a part of the truth of old wise man and was not the whole truth.
Q2:I think that the old wise man had tried to tell the three heroes the truth about him.

Reply
Trevor Wong
6/3/2022 11:43:17 am

2. I think the Old Wise will trap the heroes. It is because I think the Old Wise Man will make the heroes to work for him and continue to gather more negative items to feed Gauwa.

Reply
Nathan Chiu 5A 04
6/3/2022 11:44:39 am

1) I don’t think Nana is telling the truth since She did not present any evidence to show that the secret wise man is evil. She is just sharing her opinions with Bong.
2) if I were the heroes in the story, I would definitely attend the old man’s concert. After all, I am curious to know what kind of secrets did the old man keep.

Reply
5E 13 Zenith Lee
6/3/2022 11:45:47 am

Q1: I think that Na Na probably told the truth, because whether or not she is still working for the old wise man, Bong saved her, and she owed him a favor in the form of this info.

Reply
6A 03 Chan Ka Wing
6/3/2022 11:49:14 am

1.I think Nana is telling the truth since almost every movies or dramas' plots is about the first one they met is the boss.
I think the boss is the OLD WISE MAN from the creepy smiling Bong (bot Bong)

Reply
5C 20 Declan Mak
6/3/2022 12:05:53 pm

Q1 I think Nana is lying because in a video, a dice showed that there was a betrayer. So I think Nana is lying.

Reply
6C08 Sky Lau
6/3/2022 12:12:55 pm

Question 2.
I think that The Old Wise Man has already arranged Gauwa somewhere near his "concert", waiting to eat the so-called "negative items" in front of them, making the heroes think that they are doomed, then consume their souls of hopelessness.

Reply
6C10 Marco leung
6/3/2022 12:20:07 pm

I think Nana is telling the truth because Bong saved her from the soldiers, and I think she is finding the truth too.

Reply
6A19 Ma Hei Ting
6/3/2022 12:24:02 pm

Q1 I think Na Na is not telling the truth because she may be helping the old wise man to test the three heroes for the trust of the old wise man.
Q2 I think the old wise man intends to kill the three heroes in the "concert" and give the dead body to gauwa to eat.

Reply
6D11 Hogan Lau
6/3/2022 12:28:55 pm

Q1. I think that Nana iis telling the truth, because if she was lying, she couldn't have made up a such long story in such a short time. She also was chased by the old wise man's soldiers and captured so its obvious that the old wise man doesn't like Nana, and it makes up with the rest of the story.

Reply
5B 16 Bosco Leung
6/3/2022 12:31:27 pm

que1.I think that Nana is telling the truth because she said she has worked for the old wise man, but she also tell the secret of the old wise man to Bong.

Reply
Bosco
6/3/2022 12:38:55 pm

I don't think she has told the truth, because I don't know anything about her.
I think he itentds to show the three little heroes of his creation.

Reply
5A27 Hayden Yuen
6/3/2022 01:00:10 pm

I think the concert was a trap. It was because we all know that the old wise man created Guawa, and Bong, Chi-Yin and Hinson are hos enemy. So, why will he ever want his 'enemy' to come to his 'concert'? I think he will use the 'concert' as a bait and kill the three main characters when they arrive, to stop them from trying to defeat his creation.

Reply
5D17 Alvin Lee
6/3/2022 01:22:36 pm

Q1. I think Na Na tells the truth. She is a good friend with Bong. She fights the fake Bong, and she doesn't want the fake Bong hurts the real Bong. I think she is kind and honest, so she doesn't tell lies to Bong.

Reply
6A 09 Sheldon Cheung
6/3/2022 01:25:33 pm

1) I think she holds the truth as the old wise man was so desperate to catch her
2) I think the concert is to show feed the seven sacred items to Guawa, letting it become more powerful than ever while leading the three heroes to a trap because they know too much about the old wise man.

Reply
Anson Cing from 6A(10)
6/3/2022 01:35:49 pm

1) I think that Nana is telling the truth. It is because it was her who saved Bong. She also knew something about the old wise man and didn't agree with him, so she told the others to mind the wise, which means to prevent getting too close to the old wise man.

Reply
5C Jonas Tang
6/3/2022 01:55:35 pm

I think that Na Na is not lying as she was chased by the soldiers and if she is a bad guy,she an betray Bong when he was saving her.

I think that the old wise man might fight the three heroes with his pet monster Guawa.

Reply
5D12 Harris Kung
6/3/2022 02:10:16 pm

1)I think Na Na has told the truth because Na Na was chased by soldiers. Bong saved her so I think Na Na won't tell a lie to him.

Reply
5D06 Adrian Chung
6/3/2022 02:24:12 pm

2. I think the 'concert' that the old man was referring to is trapping the three heroes and force them to see the old wize man feeds Gawa and witness the monster conquer the world.

Reply
Harvielau5c09
6/3/2022 02:49:40 pm

1,it is almost the end of the term so I guess the plot will not have time to twist

Reply
6A06 Milton Chan
6/3/2022 03:15:40 pm

Q1) Yes, I think that Na Na told the truth because she could recall many details of the secrets she knew, and people telling a lie usually couldn’t. Also, in one of the previous chapters the Old Wise Man said “You seemed to have known a secret that is beyond your reach” to Bong. I guess the Old Wise Man didn’t want the heroes to know about his ‘secrets’ so he used his warriors to trap Na Na. The whole thing seems to be quite logical, in my opinion.

Reply
5D05 Kyle Chu
6/3/2022 03:23:55 pm

1.I think Na Na is telling the truth,because he saw the fake Bong and saved Bong.

Reply
6C07
6/3/2022 03:41:03 pm

1. I think Na Na wasn't telling the truth, because she didn't has any motivation and suddenly found the secret.

Reply
Jayden Chau 5E 02
6/3/2022 03:56:43 pm

Question 1:
I think that NaNa is telling the truth. First of all, in the previous chapter, Bong helped her a lot, so I think that NaNa is a friend of Bong and she would not trick Bong. Second of all, NaNa has the dices that are from the Old Wise Man, which means that she has worked with the Old Wise Man before. Thirdly, I think that she cannot make up this fake situation in such a short amount of time, and lastly, I think that she is very kind and she is very honest.

Reply
6B05 Ocean Hui
6/3/2022 03:57:09 pm

1:I think NaNa didn’t tell the truth because ,maybe the old wise man used something to force her not to tell others.Instead,maybe the old wise Ka used some his invention to force NaNa not to tell too.

Reply
6C26 Hayden Yuen
6/3/2022 04:26:07 pm

1. I think that Nana is telling the truth. It is because the Old Wise Man is acting strange in Chapter 5. He said," My boy, you have known too much." That means that the Old Wise Man thought that Nana had told the truth already with Bong. That is why in the Old Wise Man room has Nana captured too. Another thing to notice is that, the Old Wise Man instantly teleported the seven items and the robot directly to himself. If he wasn't using the seven items to feed Gauwa, he would wait until the heroes to return. Also, the Old Wise Man was holding the pipa in the call, that suggests that the Old Wise Man is still in the past, an action that no one could manage. That is when the robot Bong comes in. The red portal the Robot Bong has might be the tool that the Old Wise Man used to travel to the past. This explains everything and makes Nana story make sense, so I think that it is safe to trust Nana.

Reply
5A29 Adrian Yuen
6/3/2022 05:14:57 pm

1.I think nana is lying because the old wise man can build a robot bong so he can easily build a robot nana as well.

Reply
5E28 Max
6/3/2022 05:34:10 pm

1. I think that Nana is correct. It is because the Old Wise Man held the Pipa which was Nana's and the Old Wise Man immediately teleported the robot away when they got the seven sacred items.

Reply
5C08 Lai Ching Hang
6/3/2022 05:37:43 pm

I think Na Na was telling the truth. First, she explained to Bong with confidence, which didn’t seem she was lying. Moreover, endless heroes had already attempted to kill Gauwa before but in vain, so there was no point for sending the three young children to fight the powerful monster. I think the Old Wise Man just wanted to use the children to help him to gather the sacred items for the benefit of his own creation, Gauwa.

Reply
5D 23 Richard Liu
6/3/2022 05:42:26 pm

Q1. I think Nana is telling the truth about the old wise man. Up to the seventh chapter in the story, there is many evidence about the (not) Wise being sus, while there is many evidence of Nana being good.
Q2. I personally think that the Wise is going to use the music to hypnotise the three heros and capture them. Spooky! Anyway, I think the seven sacred items were the only items that could stop the Wise and his cunning plan, so when the robot disappeared it was dystroyed, taking the seven items with it... or so the Wise thought.

Reply
Isaac Lau
6/3/2022 05:47:59 pm

Q2 I think the old wise man invited the three heroes to his concert to trap and feed Gawa. As the introduction, no hero ever fight Gawa had won.

Reply
6B 20 Carlos Wong
6/3/2022 05:50:01 pm

1. I believe that Na Na is telling lies and there are a few close which led me to this conclusion.

1st. The old wise man wanted to capture Na Na and she escaped every time with Bong easily, which makes me think that the old wise man was actually letting them escape on purpose.
2nd.Why does Na Na still live in the old wise man's territory if she was a past hero who knew secrets? Logically she should have left for her own safety.
3rd. If Na Na knew the secrets so well, why did she stutter when she replied Bong whether she was a heroine?

2. The old wise man's supposed concert, in my opinion, is actually bringing the heroes and all the residents to the reveal of his master plan and the final stage (if it has one) of Gauwa.

Reply
Kingsley Wong 5a23
6/3/2022 06:10:56 pm

I think Nana told the truth because all the secretes she said were about the bad things of the old wise man and if old wise man was her boss she won’t said it out.Also up till chp. 7 many evidence showed that Nana was a good person

Reply
6B11 Sheldon Lien
6/3/2022 06:20:53 pm

Q1: I think Nana has told the truth and why she told a lot of her secrets was because that she had a similar personality like Oliver Twist, when the Old Wise Man knew that Nana knows about the secret of Gauwa, she got teleported to the Mausoleum of the First Qin Emperor, and got stuck there. Then, she found out that she needs another hero of Forgotten Land to unlock the curse to leave it. Bong went into it and Nana thought that Bong must be her saviour, so she told all the secrets to Bong.

Q2. I think the Old Wise Man invited them for the "concert" is to trap and teleport them to another place with a curse as i mentioned in the first question, and the curse is maybe the smell of Gauwa.

Reply
6C03 Ian Chow
6/3/2022 06:21:50 pm

Q2: I think the concert will be a trap organised by the old wise man. I think after the old wise man transported the three heroes to the concert, he will let Gauwa have the seven sacred items and eat the heroes. This explains why all heroes didn’t go back to Forgotten Land, they were eaten by Gauwa.

Reply
Austin Yuen
6/3/2022 07:12:04 pm

I think she had told the truth because she told Bong everything with sincere and she fought the robot Bong which maybe want to catch them back and she wrote the words in the picture Mind The Wise. So she might had told the truth but she also might not tell Bong everything because she tried to stole the pipa

Reply
Nestor Kwok 6D08
6/3/2022 07:43:56 pm

Q1.I think that NaNa is telling the truth. It is because that i think she is a kind person and she wants to beat the Old Wise Man too.

Reply
5E23
6/3/2022 08:47:28 pm

I think Na Na is telling the truth because she has been captured by the old wise man.She didn’t want to be on the side of him and might kill herself.So she will tell Bong the truth and wanted the three heroes to defeat Gauwa.

Reply
5D21 Jimmy Liu Chun Ngai
6/3/2022 09:21:19 pm

I)Na Na talks a lot about the secrets she knows. Do you think she has told the truth? What makes you believe or not believe her?

I think Na Na is telling the truth.The Old Wise Man wanted to capture👮‍♂️ Na Na everytime because he don't want Na Na to say to everyone mind the wise.Also,Na Na had the dices🎲 which were from the Old Wise Man, which means that she had worked with the Old Wise Man before.She also fought with the fake Bong and if they are the same(the same kind of people🧑/robot🦾 who are still working for the Old Wise Man),they wouldn't fight⚔,would they? She was captured by the Old Wise Man's soldiers💂‍♂️ and was a enemy of the Old Wise Man.She helped Bong a lot so I believe she was not lying.



II)The Old Wise Man seems to be "inviting" the heroes to attend his "concert". What do you think he intends to do and why?

I think the seven7️⃣ sacred items were the food🍕 of Gauwa.It could help Gauwa become the most powerful animal/robot in the world.Then,the heros would be eaten by Gauwa after they were used by Old Wise Man and haven't spread the news that to mind the wise. Nana was a special case that she didn't go to the 'concert'🎞🔊🔊 and escape from him.Therefore,he would be careful and use robots like bong to keep watch over the heros🗡.Therefore I would not believe him.

Reply
6A 17 Anson Lo
6/3/2022 09:54:40 pm

Q2) I think the Old Wise Man will hurt or murder and hold the heroes hostage as he probably intends to use the items to feed Gauwa.

Reply
5D22 Jaden Liu
6/3/2022 10:25:33 pm

1) I think Na Na is telling the truth because she stole the pipa of the Old Wise Man. Na Na will not steal his pipa if she works for him.

Reply
5A 07 Ho Lap Tak
6/3/2022 10:29:19 pm

Q1. I think Nana is telling the truth ,because Bong has save she once

Reply
5A 14 Travis Law
6/3/2022 10:52:16 pm

1. I think Na Na has told the truth.It is because while they were
chatting, the robot Bong appeared and she sacrificed to save Bong from the robot Bong.That means she wants to help Bong,so if she wants to help Bong, she will tell him the truth.
2. I think he wants the three heros to find all the items and use them to feed Guawa.

Reply
6D01 Duncan Chan
6/4/2022 12:11:43 am

I think Nana is telling the truth, or else why would the old wise man try to catch her when she left?

Reply
5E27 Wayne Tse
6/4/2022 08:20:40 am

1.I think Nana is just a spy of the old wise man, and pretended to become a "hero", in order to make Bong trust her and tell her the secrets.
2.He wants to use the heros to find the scared items to feed Guawa. After they find the items, the "Old wise" man would trap them up or kill them.

Reply
Landon Kee
6/4/2022 08:42:27 am

Q2. i think the old wise man is trying to kill them or some other trap once they arrive it

Reply
Yim Hei Long
6/4/2022 08:45:58 am

Q2. I think the Old Wise Man is wanting to catch them and kill them.

Reply
Hugo Tang
6/4/2022 08:54:25 am

Q1: I think Nana has told the truth because the Old Wise Man took all the items at last, and he is going to feed Gauwa.

Reply
5D 13 Aaron Kwok
6/4/2022 09:05:16 am

Q1.I think Nana has told the truth because Bong saved her life and she even worked for the old wise man before.

Reply
6D05 Cleatus Cheung
6/4/2022 09:22:13 am

Q1. I think Nana was telling the truth because the seven sacred items and the robot has vanished to the old wise man.

Reply
6B12 Kaspar Siu
6/4/2022 10:31:34 am

1. I think that Nana is not telling the truth because she works for the old wise man before and I think she won't suddenly betray the old wise man.

Reply
5E29
6/4/2022 10:39:50 am

I think NaNa was telling the truth because she worked for the old wise man before and she would know the secret of the old wise man.

Reply
5E29
6/6/2022 07:27:45 pm

Also because Bong saved her and she was nice, so she told the secret of the old wise man to Bong.

Reply
5b10
6/4/2022 11:19:32 am

1. Yes, I think NaNa is telling the truth because many clues support that NaNa is warning "Mine the Wise" and trying to escape the Old Wise Man's control. Therefore, she told the secrets of the Old Wise Man to Bong.

2. I think the Old Wise Man wants to capture them as they already know some secrets of him, like NaNa.

Reply
5B11
6/4/2022 11:26:12 am

1.Yes, because she had been trapped by the old wise man

Reply
Aiden Li
6/4/2022 12:03:14 pm

Q1

I think Nana is telling the truth because what Bong saw appropriates to what Nana said. Further more, Bong saved Nana from the soldiers before and Nana must be thankful and she doesn't seem like a betrayer.

Reply
5E07 Victor
6/4/2022 12:53:03 pm

Q1:
I think Nana is telling the truth, because Bong had saved her before, and after exchanging identities, it is not quite possible to have a betrayer amidst. More on, Nana saying lies doesn't ultimately help the Old Wise Man, so I believe Nana is telling the truth.

Reply
6A13 Rex Lau
6/4/2022 01:13:11 pm

1)I think Nana was not telling the truth, I think she was just helping the old wise man to see what have the three heroes done and gave some tips to them.

Reply
6B 06 Marcus Lee
6/4/2022 01:32:26 pm

2. I think the old wise man wanted to trap those three heroes. After Bong, Chi-yin, and Hinson was trapped, the old wise man will feed Gauwa those seven items and those three boys.

Reply
5B 26 Boaz Tung
6/4/2022 01:35:01 pm

1) I think Na Na is NOT telling the truth. It is because the old wise man
knows that Na Na knows his top secrets. Therefore, the old wise
man will request Na Na not to tell his top secrets but instead of
telling something fake.

2) I think the old wise man's hidden meaning of "inviting the heroes to
attend his concert" is to kill them. It is because many heroes from
the past had died to kill Gauwa, maybe the past heroes are not
dead from fighting Gauwa, but were killed by the old wise man.

Reply
6A02 Horace Chan
6/4/2022 01:58:20 pm

1. I think she could be trusted, because the Terracotta Army seems to be commanded by the Old Wise Man and after the Old Wise(plus Evil) Man told Bong that he seemed to have found a secret which should be beyond his reach, the Terracotta Army started to attack him. It is clear that the Old Wise Man is suspicious, and what Na Na said is likely to be true. As for Gauwa, it was defeated earlier, but its Deoxyribonucleic acid is collected by the Old Wise Cunning Man in order to create a power, but he accidentally created Gauwa 2.0. Then he changed plans by using Gauwa 2.0 to make the havoc instead. It’s just that the hero who defeated the evil sacrificed his/her life.
2. He may want the heroes to know the truth while it is too late to stop it. Then he will play the pipa in a certain tune that would make Gauwa awaken and unleash its ultimate power(it was just in the asleep condition when the Old Wise Man was feeding it, but the stench was still there while it was sleeping, and after the Old Wise Man feeds the items the trio gave him to the monster, Gauwa will enter the final stage) and kill them first. It was because the Old Wise Man wants to do something evil, like conquering the whole universe of universes, and he needs Gauwa’s power. And that’s why he needed to chase Na Na when she stole the pipa for good. And as the Chinese proverb says, “You have to shoot the horse before shooting the horseman, and catch the leader before catching the bandits”, the Old Wise Man has to kill the three heroes quickly before they could tell the truth to the citizens of Forgottenland and defeat Gauwa.
Now everything makes sense.

Reply
6A02 Horace Chan
6/4/2022 02:15:10 pm

The trio are the "horses" and "leaders" from the proverb, and the citizens are the "horsemen" and "bandits".
Feel free to leave a reply to my comment! :)

Reply
Michael Lam
6/4/2022 02:09:50 pm

I think the old wise man intends to hypnotize the heroes because he is scared that the heroes will be powerful enough to stop him from conquering the world with Gauwa

Reply
Jasper Chan
6/4/2022 02:48:01 pm

2. I believe that the old wise man is actually trying to trap the three heros and hypnotise them into his own prison that he used to trap the old heros as their use to find the items had been completed and so did they has no use for the old wise man.

Reply
5C23 Cedric To
6/4/2022 02:58:47 pm

1. I think Nana told the truth because she looks kind and won't lie.
2. I the old wise man trade them

Reply
5E18 Marcus Li
6/4/2022 03:07:47 pm

1.I think NaNa is telling the truth,it is because the old wise man captured Bong,that means he is evil,but than Bong escaped with NaNa so NaNa wanted to tell him the truth and defeat the old wise man together.

Reply
5D10 James Jim
6/4/2022 03:07:49 pm

1) I think Na Na is telling the truth. It is because guards chased NaNa,and they wouldn’t chase her if she was a friend of the old wise man.

2) I think the old wise man's hidden meaning of "inviting the heroes to
attend his concert" is to kill them. It is because many heroes from
the past had died to kill Gauwa, maybe the past heroes are not
dead from fighting Gauwa, but were killed by the old wise man.

Reply
Julius Zhu 6C 28
6/4/2022 03:16:49 pm

I think nana is telling a part of the truth nut not all of them .It is because she has been worked for the old wise man and I think if she tells them all the truth , the old wise man will find out that the one who told secrets is Nana.She may be killed.

Reply
6C17Matthew Sin
6/4/2022 03:20:01 pm

Q1. I think she has told the truth. It was because she has no hesitation while she were speaking confidently and I could see her loyalty to Bong and his teamates.

Reply
6A04 Hayers Chan
6/4/2022 03:30:36 pm

I think the Old Wise Man want them to join him and make a new monster out like Gauwa. The Old Wise Man needs the seven items to feed Gauwa and make it strong so he can control him to hold the world.

Reply
Horace Lee 5E 12
6/4/2022 03:35:35 pm

2(a)I think the Old Wise Man intends to broadcast Guawa wrecking cities and he also wants to takeover the world
2(b)I think the Old Wise Man invited the three boys to the “concert” because he wanted them to feel guilty about what they did.

Reply
5A24 Anson Wong
6/4/2022 04:05:21 pm

Q1.Yes,I think Na Na is telling the truth , because she went in the mist to fight or get the robot Bong , and the real Bong saved her life.
Q2.I think the old wise intended to lure them into the concert and capture them , then use the seven saved items to feed Gauwa , and lastly kill the boys and say that they failed thei mission.

Reply
5C 01 Charlie Au Yeung
6/4/2022 04:22:24 pm

Q1. I think NaNa is telling the truth. It is because NaNa's story-telling of her experience seems very true and she did not have any strange acts when telling her stories to Bong, so I think she is telling the truth.

Reply
Matthew Choy 5B 07
6/4/2022 04:28:25 pm

Q1. I think Na Na is making up stories because it appears that the Old Wise Man is going to take advantage of the heroes, trapping them.

Q2. I think the Old Wise Man is cunning and intends to trap them such that he could feed Guawa.

Reply
5C11 Bosco Lee
6/4/2022 04:36:26 pm

Q1: I think NaNa is telling the truth. It is because (1)she doesn’t look like a betrayer, (2)Bong saved her life, (3)if she was lying, what good will it do to her?

Reply
Brendan Li 5D18
6/4/2022 04:37:54 pm

I think Nana wasn't telling the truth,because Nana know many thing about the old wise man,she said she is good,but how did Nana know all these things about the old wise man??

Reply
Tong Yui Him
6/4/2022 04:43:59 pm

Q2: I think the old wise man was trying to trap the three heroes. It is because the “concert” might be a distract that of the three heroes going to a mysterious place. The old wise man may try to hypnotise the heroes and get their powers, like the strength of Chi-yin standing up. The old wise man might want to become by younger stealing these strength the by the heroes.

Reply
Jason Ng 5D27
6/4/2022 04:53:20 pm

Q1.I think that Nana is telling the truth ,because she said she works for the old wise man and she looks like a kind girl.
Q2.I think the old wise man will kill the three heros by the strength of Guawa.

Reply
5D24 Cyrus
6/4/2022 04:58:18 pm

Q1:I think Nana has told the truth, because she's attitude is very sincere.

Reply
5D26 Nok Chun
6/4/2022 05:20:53 pm

1) I think the Old Wise Man is bad because he is the one that made Guawa.
2)I think Nana is telling the truth because I think she is a very kind girl, also she told bong that she worked for the Old Wise Man.

Reply
Hendrick
6/4/2022 05:40:04 pm

1.I think Nana is telling the truth because Bong helped her to escape from the old man.

Reply
Li Ching Hei
6/4/2022 05:55:15 pm

Q.2 I think the old wise man wanted to kill the heroes because he is one of the followers of Gawa and he is required to destroy the heroes.

Reply
6D06 Sheldon Hui
6/4/2022 07:11:36 pm

1.Yes, I think NaNa is telling the truth because she did not have reasons to lie. The first time Bong met NaNa, she was trying to steal the pipa-which has a high possibility of being a part of the Wise's plan, and that explains that NaNa was trying to stop the plan and is clearly innocent.
2.I think the Wise is trying to use the seven broken items and the pipa to summon Gauwa (as it mentioned that Gauwa is kind of like the Wise's servant or pet), and kill or use the heros to finish his plan.

Reply
5A 31
6/4/2022 08:08:48 pm

1. I think that Nana is telling to truth because Bong saved him and she is pleased with Bong.

Reply
5E11 Aron Law
6/4/2022 08:29:50 pm

I don't think that Nana is telling the truth, because she seems to know to much about the Old Wise Man surly has the technology to catch Nana to stop her from meeting Bong and telling him the truth. That why i think that Nana is an impostor .

Reply
5E 09 Lawrence Lau
6/4/2022 08:36:11 pm

Q1.I think that Na Na has told the truth because she is a kind woman.The other thing I think that she told the truth was because Bong had helped her to escape from the soldiers so she would help Bong once.

Reply
6D04 Glendon Cheong
6/4/2022 08:46:28 pm

I think Na Na has told the truth because Bong had saved her and also helped her to escaped.
Na Na said that she always told the people to “Mind the Wise”. That meant Na Na was scared of the monster, Gauwa.

Reply
EdwinCheung6A08
6/4/2022 08:46:47 pm

1.I think NaNa still hadn't told the truth.I know the other side may say "Wait,NaNa was saved by Bong and she must be telling the truth,right?"And here it is:remember that she might also IS one of the members.NaNa told Bong that she was one,but she didn't said she IS one.The whole thing be like:NaNa spied on the three(four then) heroes and made the hula-hoop of Bong's teleport to the underground world.She then pretended to escape from the solders and tried to be friends with Bong.And therefore,her "background" may be fake,or at least,unreliable.
2.The "concert" may be just like Hong Mun Banquet(that's what the translater said) in Qin dynasty.Withing the inferences above,The so-called "concert" may be where there our four heroes battle against The old "wise"man,NaNa,the robot and "Guawa".The old "wise" man(yeah,very "wise" indeed)found out that "Guawa"needed souls to nourish itself one day.And there is why the rumors started.
You now might be thinking:wait Edwin,you just said that we should not trust NaNa,but the whole inference basing on NaNa's words.OK,I must clarify that NaNa might claim some real things in between to make it SOUNDS reliabe,and there was not much of other options left,so this one was still the trust-worthy ones.
Again,this is only my inferences,so don't blame me for drawing inferences wrongly.
:)

Reply
Still Edwin
6/4/2022 09:13:27 pm

Remember the dice was written"fake"(I care it as an imposter)and it not only refers to The old "wiise" man,but also to NaNa.

Reply
Sky Yang 5C 32
6/4/2022 08:47:30 pm

I think Nana was not telling the truth.It was because the old wise man
is going to trap them.

Reply
Jamie Ng
6/4/2022 08:49:22 pm

Q.2 I thinks he wants to change Chi-Yin and Hinson to robot.

Reply
6A 20 Mitch Milas
6/4/2022 08:57:31 pm

Q1. I think that Nana is telling the truth since she is really supportive on the heroes side. Not only that, it was her who gave the heroes the third item. She also told everybody different clues about the Old "Wise" Man. To me, I think she is trustable because the Old Wise Man wants her to be caught and I don't think she would like that to happen and still work on his side.

Q2. I think the Old Wise Man is just tricking the heroes to going to his concert. I think there is a trap there set for them. He probably wants to pretend that Gauwa had trapped the heroes but want to be innocent to get the people of the city's trust.

Reply
4B29 Caspian Yeung
6/4/2022 09:04:10 pm

Q.1:I think na na is not lying, it is because she has the dice and hula hoop portal that the old wise man gave to Hinson and Bong as well. So, she is clearly not lying that she worked for the old wise man.
Q.2:I think he intends to trap and collect the boys DNA, to create Gawua 2.0,telling the boys to collect the seven sacred items to stall some time, to finish the main body of Gawua 2.0.(powered by the boys DNA.)Gawua was real, just killed by one of the heroes.

Reply
Marcus wan
6/4/2022 09:04:41 pm

Q1 .I think we should believe because bong save her and she is trustful

Reply
5B 21
6/4/2022 09:25:04 pm

I think Nana is lying because he didn't told that to Bong at first and I think she just want those scared items.

Reply
5B 09
6/4/2022 09:31:37 pm

1.I think nana treat Bong is a good friend because he told everything about the old wise man.
2. I think nana is telling the truth because if she was lying she don't need to give one of the secret item to Bong

Reply
Adan Lam 5D14
6/4/2022 09:43:07 pm

Q2.I think the old wise man invite the heros is to kill them because they know all the secrets of the old wise man

Reply
Nathan Chan
6/4/2022 09:55:04 pm

I think Na Na is telling the truth as if she was bad then she wouldn’t tell bong about the secrets of the old wise man to make them suspect him.

Reply
Ethan Lee 5C13
6/4/2022 10:01:43 pm

I think NaNa is telling the truth, because if she is not why will the old man call out guards to chase them and second why will he made the robot disappear or (the robot disappear by itself) and trap the three heroes

Reply
Ethan Lee 5C13
6/4/2022 10:36:15 pm

Nana could be telling the truth because Bong save her two times
and she maybe have to tell him the truth

Reply
Kingsley Wong 5C27
6/4/2022 10:49:30 pm

Q.1 I think Na Na didn’t tell the truth. I have two reasons to support: 1. In the story, Na Na told Bong that she worked for the old wise man before and she might be a spy for the old wise man. 2. When Na Na recognised the robot Bong, she flew to it and disappeared which made me think that the old wise man had told Na Na to go back to find him and the robot Bong might be a mark for Na Na, who finished the mission of knowing the secrets of the three heroes.

Reply
5C 28
6/4/2022 10:58:44 pm

I think NaNa is a liar because she might be still working for The Old Wise Man she just told Bong that the old wise man was secrettive but still left her alive even after she knew his secret

Reply
6D 15
6/5/2022 07:00:40 am

2:I personally think if Nana had told the truth, the old wise man could be trying to trap the heroes, this also explains why the heroes were unsuccessful in the past ,and that Nana might be the one who has escaped.

Reply
5B12
6/5/2022 08:13:20 am

Q.1 I think that Nana knew Bong and his friends could stop the old wise man, so she told a lot of secrets to Bong.
Q.2 I think the old wise man will kill them because he does not want anyone to stop him.

Reply
5A09
6/5/2022 08:55:38 am

1)
i think Na Na is telling the truth. It's because Bong saved her before in chapter 3. Maybe she thinks that the old wise man's behavior is really bad. Moreover, she wants to help the three heroes to defeat Gawua.
2)
I think the old wise man is too afraid to defeat Gawua. Moreover, he is very old. Or maybe the old wise man is a bad person and he wants to leave a very strong monster in Forgotten land to let Gawua defeat the strong people.

Reply
6c14
6/5/2022 09:39:44 am

Q2.I think the old wise man wanted to invite them to a place and use the seven items to respond gauwa In front of them and tell gauwa you defeat them

Reply
5B 14 Eitan Lai
6/5/2022 10:24:39 am

2)
I think the old wise man will use the seven items to feed gauwa to make it become stronger and let it defeat those hero

Reply
Jayden Ma 5A 19
6/5/2022 10:33:17 am

1. I think Nana is telling the truth because she gave the sacred item to Bong, and she does not look like a betrayer
2. Because the old wise man wanted to kill All of the heroes and make a new pair of heroes to find him the food for his pet

Reply
6D03 Gordon Chang
6/5/2022 11:44:43 am

2. I think that the Old Wise Man is the one who is actually evil. The seven sacred items are just to feed Gauwa. The Old Wise Man may trap the three heroes in the concert.

Reply
Noah Chan 6D2
6/5/2022 11:45:53 am

2. I think the Old Wise Man is "inviting" them to the "concert" which is actually a trap, and the Old Wise Man will try to kill them and Na Na.

Reply
Jasper Tang
6/5/2022 12:00:23 pm

2. Because if the heros go there the old wise man can capture them , because the old wise man is lazy <he needs people to help him collect items so we can see he is EXTREMELY lazy> he doesn't want to move

Reply
5D 11 Moses Kan
6/5/2022 12:10:10 pm

2. I think the Old Wise Man wants to trap the three heroes. It is because the video said that the seven sacred items that the heroes got were to feed Gauwa to let it grow stronger , so I think the Old Wise Man will trap them for his master evil plan to work !

Reply
5B 30 Marco Yip
6/5/2022 12:14:49 pm

1. I think NaNa is telling the truth if she is not she won’t give the item to Bong.
2. I think the old wise man is evil because after Bong met him, there is a fake Bong appeared and I think the old wise man created him.

Reply
6A 14 Kado Law
6/5/2022 12:21:15 pm

1. I think that Na Na is not lying and that she is trustable by Bong. It is because Bong saved Na Na, and I don't think Na Na would lie to a person who saved her life!

Reply
Myron Cheung
6/5/2022 12:56:30 pm

Q2. I think that the reason the Old Wise Man seems to be inviting the trio to his concert is because he wants their power. As said in the beginning, many powerful heroes have tried to defeat Gauwa but in vain. I think that the Old Wise Man created Gauwa to achieve immortality, but he needed Gauwa alive in order to live forever. Therefore, he sent the heroes to collect the so called ‘sacred items’, and when they come back with the items, not only he will feed the items to him, Gauwa will also absorb the negative energy of the heroes, making him more powerful. Then, Gauwa will use his power to grant the Old Wise Man immortality.

Reply
6D10 Martin
6/5/2022 01:38:08 pm

1) I don’t think Na Na would lie to someone that saved her life. Instead I think she was telling the truth about all the secrets of the old Wise Man.
2) I think the old Wise Man was trying to maybe trap them, since I think he is an evil person.

Reply
5A12
6/5/2022 02:38:25 pm

I think NaNa has told the truth and has worked for the Old Wise Man before since if she hasn’t told the truth , she will not give the sacred item to Bong

Reply
5B 22
6/5/2022 02:40:16 pm

Q2. I think the reason why The Old Wise Man told the heroes to attend the "concert" is that he want to kill them and kidnap the robot to get the sacred items.

Reply
5E10
6/5/2022 02:42:35 pm

I think that Nana is telling the truth because it makes sense and I don’t think that nana is going to harm the boys.

Reply
5D09 JAYDEN
6/5/2022 02:58:03 pm

1. I think nana's secrets are fake because in the TV, the old wise man is holding the pipa from nana

Reply
5A 28 Roderick Yuen
6/5/2022 03:19:02 pm

Question #1: I do not believe that Na Na is telling the truth. For one, her story is too in sync with Bong’s current suspicion that the Old Wise Man is evil (not that I believe in “good” or “evil”). After seemingly being captured by the Old Wise Man, Bong of course believes that the Old Wise Man is not as innocent as he seems. By re-affirming Bong’s suspicion and adding new extravagant details to the mix, Na Na successfully gains Bong’s trust and makes him hate the Old Wise Man even more. To me, this seems like some manipulation is taking place. If I were to manipulate one of the heroes, I would of course choose Bong, as he is quite hot-headed and impulsive, and thinks with his heart, not his brain. The fact that neither Hinson nor Chi-Yin, who appear to be more intelligent, were approached by Na Na makes the possibility of her manipulating Bong even more suspicious. Furthermore, if Na Na’s job was to collect items for the Old Wise Man, then why would she be chased by the terracotta army (which was in the control of the Old Wise Man) after “stealing” a pipa string? She was going to give it to Bong anyway, who was sure to transfer it to the Old Wise Man. Therefore, this self-contradiction makes it evident that Na Na is working against Bong, Chi-yin, and Hinson. Finally, Bong’s final two questions, which would potentially give her away if she was lying, were not answered by Na Na because she was “interrupted” by the timely (perhaps too timely) appearance of the robot Bong. The obvious conclusion to draw from this is that Na Na is NOT telling the truth. This hypothesis fits perfectly because Na Na even has a motive – being banished to a sub-area of Forgottenland made her desire revenge.

Question #2: The Old Wise Man’s brief message has a hidden, unspoken implication: he holds Na Na hostage, or at least he claims to. In Chapter 5, when he captured Na Na and Bong, the Old Wise Man was also seen to be stroking Na Na’s pipa. Him stroking the pipa again probably is a lure for the heroes to meet him, since Bong is apparently smitten with Na Na. If he was not stroking the pipa, then the heroes would not have met him as he was quite questionable. I do not necessarily think that the Old Wise Man would kill Na Na, but probably insurance that the heroes would arrive is necessary for the Old Wise Man’s plans. So what is the Old Wise Man’s master plan for the three “heroes”? Some believe that the Old Wise Man wants to kill the three heroes, but this is just too intuitive to be true. My hypothesis is that the Old Wise Man will reveal to the heroes what I think is Gauwa’s big secret – that is, he doesn’t exist. I think this case of “Gauwa” originates from some myth about a monster who haunts the mountains to scare children, but some person believed that myth and started blaming their own unhappiness on it. The result was that everyone believed, and because they believed, they naturally became unhappy. Believing something is true results in that thing becoming true. For example, Chi-yin thought he couldn’t walk, and because he thought that he became disabled. The evidence for this outlandish claim are as follows: 1) the Old Wise Man sighed after sending out the heroes, and 2) all of the other heroes were unsuccessful in defeating Gauwa, even though collecting the sacred items was easy, reflected by how the three heroes did not encounter many problems when collecting the items. Or perhaps there has been a flaw in my logical process thus far. If this hypothesis is mistaken, then the story would probably proceed with the Old Wise Man telling the heroes the way to defeat Gauwa. Since I will assume that Na Na is not to be trusted (i.e. “evil”), I think she would probably join forces with Gauwa and try to defeat the heroes and Old Wise Man.

Reply
6C09Kyle Law
6/5/2022 03:40:23 pm

Q1. I think that Nana is telling truth because she looks reliable for not betraying them.

Reply
6C06 Jairus Ko
6/5/2022 03:45:04 pm

Q.2 I think the old wise man tries to lure the heroes and maybe hid them somewhere else so nobody would found out where there heroes are and think that the heroes has died while fighting the creation of the old wise man : guawa.

Reply
Luke Chan
6/5/2022 03:51:38 pm

I think Nana is telling a lie,as you can see the three heros think that Nana is correct but they never heard the old wise man's words so maybe Nana is bad and using them

Reply
5A17 Carlos Leung
6/5/2022 04:19:35 pm

Q2. I think the "concert" that the Old Wise Man invited the three heroes to go is a trap. The Old Wise Man will kidnap them in the "concert" and kill them, he will also feed the seven sacred items to Gauwa. Then, everyone will think the three heroes are killed by Guawa.

Reply
6C04 Tony Choy
6/5/2022 05:09:19 pm

Q2. I think the old wise man wants to kill the young heroes because with his highly advanced technology, he was probably tracking the heroes all the time and knew that they have found out too much. Therefore, if the heroes return to Forgottenland, the old wise man would be exposed and his creation -Guawa- would probably get brutally murdered.

Reply
5E 24 Daniel So
6/5/2022 05:52:29 pm

2. I think the old wise man intends to capture the three heroes and imprison them. Maybe he did that to every other hero who succeeded. Maybe that is why all the other heroes never came back.

Reply
5A02 Morgan Chan
6/5/2022 06:26:37 pm

2. The old wise man wants to feed the three heroes to Gauwa because he could just simply send out robots to collect the seven sacred items, instead, he sent out three humans to collect them, so the concert could be a trap to feed the three heroes to Gauwa.

Reply
5D25 Hayden Ma
6/5/2022 06:33:32 pm

1.I think NaNa is lying because she tells them a lot of the Old Wise Man.Maybe she created Gauwa and blames it on the Old Wise Man.Then,make the three heroes help her defeat the Old Wise Man.
2.I think the Old Wise Man is trying to make the three heroes lure NaNa to him and then reward them.

Reply
5A(22) Kingsley Wai
6/5/2022 07:03:22 pm

(1) I think Na Na was telling the truth. It is because according to Chapter 5, Bong disappeared after he met the Old Wise Man and this tells us that the Old Wise Man was evil! Nana should be right that Gauwa was made by the Old Wise Man and the Old Wise Man had a evil plan. So, Nana hoped the three heroes to stop Old Wise Man and not give the seven sacred items to Gauwa.

(2) I think the Old Wise Man wanted to kill the three heroes because he already found that Nana had told the three heroes about his secret, and he didn’t want anyone to disrupt his evil plan. Also, as Gauwa liked eating large items, the three heroes might become Gauwa’s ‘dim sum’ and it might become even more powerful!

Reply
5B06
6/5/2022 07:11:44 pm

I think The Old Wise Man will first give the seven item to Gauwa then ask the heroes where is Na Na and let Gauwa to kill the heroes. It is because he doesn't want anyone to stop him.

Reply
6B09 Marcus Leung
6/5/2022 07:36:11 pm

Q1. I don't think Na Na is talking the truth. It is because she said that she was a '' heroine '' of the old wise man. However, according to her speech, the old wise man was evil, so why didn't he kill Na Na to stop her from telling the other '' heroes'' ? Also, as a normal '' heroine '', why she will know so much about the old wise man '' secrets '' ?Therefore, I think that the old wise man was threatened by Na Na to pretend to chase her and Bong to get the '' heroes '' trust. I know this because in the introduction, after the three '' heroes '' jumped into the portal, he sighed.

Reply
5D04 Elaeth Chong
6/5/2022 08:11:07 pm

Q1: I think that she is telling the truth, because she said many things that are very reasonable, and she wouldn't tell people to mind the wise if she still works for the old wise man.

Reply
6B17 Ian Tsang
6/5/2022 08:17:51 pm

Q1. I think Nana is the old wise man's reliable assistant. I think that the so called the evil plan is something that Nana make up and tell the heroes to where and where because the heroes trusted Nana.
Q2. The robot's suddent vanish mabye appear in the old wise man's "concert". The old wise man might have to kill the heroes and fed Gauwa with it. The old wise man may pretend that the heroes died in vain and select another heroes and to let Gauwa destroy the city and be the dominator of the land and let a lot of citisens to work for him.( This is just a predition. Don't take it too serious and wait for the next chapter to release:))

Reply
6A27 Jayden Wong
6/5/2022 08:20:03 pm

I think she is telling the truth.It is because the old wise man kidnap her and Bong is the one who save Nana.

Reply
6C24 Thomas Wong
6/5/2022 09:27:20 pm

Q1. I think Nana was not telling the truth because she seemed to know a lot about the old wise man and didn't have evidence to prove that she is telling the truth.

Reply
6B04 Ethan Choy
6/5/2022 09:28:05 pm

I think the old wise man wanted to let the three heros to get the materials he wanted, instead of defeating Gauwa.

Reply
6B15 Hayden To
6/5/2022 09:30:21 pm

1.I think Na Na is telling the truth.It’s because she was helping Bong the whole time and she was risking her life to tell Bong about the old wise man’s secret since she was escaping from him






Reply
5B18 Asher Li
6/5/2022 09:35:48 pm

Q.1: I believe that Na Na has told part of the truth but not the whole truth. I believe her because she was locked by the old wise man and she said to mind the wise. Her knowledge about the old wise man may be true but I believe that there is more to the story. Na Na gasped when she saw the robot Bong, I think she might recognize the robot as the old wise man's loyal servants. Na Na has stole a pipa from the old wise man, I guess the reason the old wise man was so angry was because the pipa was an enchanted instrument to calm Gauwa and make him stronger. In the story, Na Na tells Bong that the old wise man has his own evil plans, this statement is very unclear and the plans could include defeating the heroes with Gauwa.

Reply
6D16Ethan Luk
6/5/2022 10:10:07 pm

Q1 I think that Nana is telling the truth. It is because that Bong is a person who saved her from danger, so I think Bong is a trustable person to Nana. Nana won't lie to him except she is controlled by Gauwa.(the evil side)

Reply
5E14 Lee Yui Him
6/5/2022 10:59:16 pm

2.I think The Old Wise Man is going to let them go to some crowded places,and when they found they have been tricked and getting out of the place ,he will feed Gauwa with the “negative” sacred items.

Reply
5A 03
6/6/2022 09:19:22 am

Q1 Yes,I do think Na Na is speaking the truth,because she seems trustworthy .

Reply
Kingstin Yuen
6/6/2022 01:49:14 pm

Q.1
I think she Is telling the truth.It is because Bong saved Nana's life.If she was caught by the soldiers, she would die.Fortunately, she was saved by Bong that day.

Reply
5A 10 Engus lai
6/6/2022 02:50:51 pm

Q1 I think the Nana is telling the truth because she want to warn the group

Reply
Matthew Li
6/6/2022 02:54:53 pm

1.I think Nana is telling the truth because she is one of the members on the team and she want to warn the group.

Reply
5E01 Marcus Chan
6/6/2022 03:16:02 pm

Q1: I think that Na Na is telling the truth. It is because Bong has saved her from being catch so she tells Bong as much as she knows about The Old Wise Man to let them know that he is not the man as they think of and warns them to be careful of him.
Q2:I think The Old Wise Man is tricking them by saying “ To his concert” but actually bringing them to a not pleasant place (maybe to meet Gauwa).

Reply
5E 21 Ethan Ngai
6/6/2022 07:15:59 pm

Q1. I think that Na Na is telling the truth. It is because she could be enslaved by the Old Wise Man like the other heroes who had found the seven sacred items in the past, so that explains why she also has a hula hoop that works as a portal. She betrayed the Old Wise Man because she didn’t want Bong and the other two heroes to find the seven sacred items just to make Gauwa more and more powerful. Q2. I think the Old Wise Man is planning to make a little exhibit for the three young heroes just to show them how powerful Gauwa is now and then he will imprison them after “the concert” has ended.

Reply
Aaricleung 5E
6/6/2022 08:37:17 pm

Q1, I think Na Na is telling a lie because she said the old wise man created gauwa, but the legend has been around for centuries and the old wise man could not have been around for that long and why would she steal the pipa when she already knows the old wise man's secrets?

Reply
Brandon fung 5e
6/6/2022 09:01:04 pm

1, I believe that Nana is telling the truth, because she seems to know her way around everything, and by the way,you wouldn’t lie to someone who saved you, wouldn’t you?
2 With all of Nana’s information, I think that the concert is a trick to lure the heroes back to forgottenland and a chance for the old wise man do something terrible while everyone celebrates and is distracted.

Reply
6A15 Timothy Li
6/6/2022 10:41:31 pm

2. I think the Old Wise Man was just want to prank the three heroes.

Reply
5E03ThomasCheung
6/6/2022 10:49:49 pm

2. I think the Old Wise Man wanted to invite the heroes to his "concert" because he wanted to feed Gauwa and then kill the 3 heroes, than recrut new heroes. Then make it a cycle.

Reply
5A (06) Lucius Ha Ching
6/9/2022 03:21:13 pm

Q1.I believe Nana is talking the truth because Bong help Nana from the soldiers so I think she isn’t betrayer

Reply
6A25 Alvin Tam
6/10/2022 06:51:37 pm

Q2. I think that the old wise man tried to trap the three heros when they go to the concert.

Reply
6A 11 Curtis Ho
6/10/2022 07:02:08 pm

I think that the old wise man will attempt to trap the three children and feed them to Guawa.🍽️🍽️🍽️🍽️

Reply
6A29 Kaden Yuen
6/11/2022 12:20:09 am

Q1. I think Na Na has told the truth because Bong saved her before and the old wise man is the evil ones. Also, Na Na‘s secrets are all make sence.

Reply
Kaden CHAN
6/11/2022 08:12:13 am

I think the old wise man is trying to kill the heroes.

Reply
6A01 Rex Au Yeung
6/11/2022 03:16:01 pm

Q1. I think Nana is not telling the truth and I think she is a robot. Nana is controled by the old wise man and Nana pretented to be on the hero's side. Se got the hero's trust and suddenly betary them. Therefore the old wise man can get the secret items to feed Gauwa and kill the heros easily.

Reply
6a12HeliumLam
6/11/2022 06:11:59 pm

1. I think Nana is telling the truth because Bong had helped and saved Nana before, so I think Nana will tell Bong the truth.

Reply
6A23 Evis
6/12/2022 09:50:57 pm

Q1. I don't think Na Na has told the truth. It is because she is acting a bit suspicious at the ending part of the chapter. She just disappeared from the mysterious fog above the mercury lake right before the Old Wise Man appears on the screen of the robot. This makes me think that Na Na is trying to hide some sort of secrets.

Reply
Ethan Lee 5C 13
6/24/2022 05:32:36 pm

Q.1 I think Nana is telling the truth because if she is mot why she would be chase by the old wise man people? And she have save the three heroes by taking away the "robot Bong". And I think the robot lend them to the sacred items . But there are something fishy why will Nana give one of the sacred items "the Pipa string" in the first place? that makes no sense!!??
Q.2 I think the "concert" means showing the people in the forgotten land that how powerful is Gauwa is now ,I think that the old wise man is thinking to run off the people in forgotten land to make himself king . I think the "concert" means destroying forgotten land.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    August 2020
    June 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015

    English News

    We'll update you on our thoughts and activities! Visit us often!

    Categories

    All

Home
News
Awards
Publications
English Language Curriculum
English Room
Videos
Gallery
Contact Us
Picture
© English Department, Ying Wa Primary School 2023
  • Home
  • News
  • Awards
    • Yearly Highlights
    • Speech Festival
    • Hong Kong Budding Poets Award
    • Hong Kong Young Writers Awards
    • Drama Festival
    • Debating Contests
  • Publications
    • FLAME Magazine
    • Anthologies
    • ACE Journal
    • Articles / Reports
  • English Language Curriculum
    • Language Arts >
      • Speech Gala
      • Drama in English
      • Creative Writing Competition >
        • 2021-2022 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2020-2021 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2019-2020 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2018-2019 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2017-2018 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2016-2017 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2015-2016 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
        • 2014-2015 >
          • Primary 1
          • Primary 2
          • Primary 3
          • Primary 4
          • Primary 5
          • Primary 6
    • Reading Programmes >
      • Children's Literature
      • RSTS
      • Reading Log
      • Reading Championship
  • English Room
    • Book Recommendations
  • Videos
    • Videos 2022-2023
    • Videos 2021-2022
    • Videos 2020-2021
    • Videos 2019-2020
    • Videos 2018-2019
    • Videos 2017-2018
    • Videos 2016-2017
    • Videos 2015-2016
    • Videos 2014-2015
    • Videos 2013-2014
    • Videos 2012-2013
  • Gallery
    • Snapshots 2021-2022
    • Snapshots 2020-2021
    • Snapshots 2019-2020
    • Snapshots 2018-2019
    • Snapshots 2017-2018
    • Snapshots 2016-2017
    • Snapshots 2015-2016
    • Snapshots 2014-2015
  • Contact